September 2, 2010
Ping: What Happened?
Apple announced and released a new product yesterday called Ping. It's a social network inside iTunes that is supposed to connect people around shared musical tastes, or help you find new music your friends like.
According to my Twitter friends, it's a pretty nasty flop. It turns out that Apple doesn't know people very well; they know design, product engineering, operating systems, and marketing, but they don't know people.
Apple's success to-date has been largely the result of building exactly what they want to build, and then convincing the world that it's what we need. That's not hard because they build beautiful products.
But when it comes to sharing ideas with people, beauty isn't what people expect. We've been conditioned by Facebook, MySpace, Twitter, and Linked In to expect a deeply personal and social experience without concern for award-winning design. So, when Apple thought that the path to hardware greatness (gorgeous product design) would lead them to social media greatness, they were wrong.
The Ellusive Silver Bullet
Native integration is constantly touted as the killer feature. Google put Buzz in Gmail expecting every Gmail user to swoon, leaving Twitter in droves for the warmth of tight integration, but Buzz is now just a relic gathering dust. Websites swarm to make Facebook and Twitter their native account sign-in instead of traditional user accounts and see a 75%-90% drop in new users signing up. And now Apple makes the same false assumption, that tight integration with iTunes will cause the masses to flock to Ping.
Right now, Apple should stick to what it knows: product design/engineering, innovative software, and excellent marketing/sales. Let someone else duke-it-out in the social space.

Comments [2]