Scott Magdalein

[a mélange of links, riffs, and prose on current web and mobile trends] 

March 3, 2010

AT&T Ditches Google Search on Android in Favor of Yahoo!

A recent hands-on by Engadget’s Chris Zeigler found that all of the default Google search was taken out of the device and replaced with Yahoo search (which will use Bing soon enough). Let me repeat that; all Google search is taken out of AT&T’s Android device in favor of Yahoo search.

First, this reeks of decision-making from the accountants at AT&T. They see that revenues need to climb, so they take logical actions:

  • Kill Google's search and bring in Yahoo!'s search because Yahoo! is willing to split the mobile search profits with you.
  • Bring in the Motoblur skin of the FREE Android OS to keep costs down and easily implement immediate social interaction within the device.
  • Build an intriguing enough design that kids will think it's an upgrade from their Sidekick and buy it, not knowing that it's the cheapest "smartphone" AT&T has ever sold for enormous profits.

Second, this deal stinks for the AT&T customers because:

  • Yahoo! search isn't as good as Google's search.
  • With search built into every app and web-search is accessible from every location on the phone, a Yahoo! replacement is going to make for a slow and disconnected experience.
  • It smells too strongly of corporate decision-making on a granular level.

It's a sad state for AT&T if the first Android phone they land doesn't even bring in the most intriguing aspect; amazing search capabilities baked in.

Loading mentions Retweet

Comments (4)

Mar 03, 2010
 said...
To ditch Google was a huge mistake. Yahoo doesnt hold a candle to Google. Google get better and better with their products. Maybe Yahoo will pick up the pace...
Mar 03, 2010
jt said...
There has to be more to it than just revenue because Google does ad splits if you go with the Google experience on an Android phone... unless Yahoo was paying more, but for some reason I don't see that as likely
Mar 04, 2010
Micah Choquette said...
Google just bought Picnik, which is the default image editor for Flickr, owned by Yahoo. Will Google buy Yahoo anyway and leave it all moot? How is google responding to this?
Mar 04, 2010
Scott Magdalein said...
@Bane, no doubt that Yahoo! can't compete with Google on search.

@jt, I know what you mean, but why else would they remove the best search option and go with the second (or third) option on the list? The only reason that makes sense is revenue sharing that's better than Google's offer.

@Micah, Highly doubt that Google will buy Yahoo! since Bing and Yahoo!'s search are joining forces to take on Google. But we'll see...

I try not to write negative blog posts because there are plenty of them out there, but this move just rubs me the wrong way. Google gives them a free mobile OS and they slap them in the face.

 
Got an account with one of these? Login here, or just enter your comment below.
Posterous-login    Connect    twitter