Scott Magdalein

[a mélange of links, riffs, and prose on current web and mobile trends] 

November 7, 2009

Leadership Without Inspiration is Management

Penelope Trunk, founder of Brazen Careerist, wrote recently about President Obama's Nobel win. The reason for the win is that he, essentially, inspires people like no one else in history. (First, I'm happy for him. That's a huge honor and he should be proud. Second, inspiration alone should not win someone a Nobel Prize of any kind.)

However, the discussion brings up a great point; namely, that the greatest leaders are also the greatest inspirers. To be sure, leadership (true leadership) can't happen without inspiration. Leading without inspiring is management (and possibly poor management).

Inspiration comes in as many forms as there are people leading through it, but the results are usually similar: happy people and forward progress. During the reign of Jack Welch, General Electric was an innovation leader because of his inspirational leadership. Joel Osteen has led Lakewood Church to be the largest church in America (50k+ people) purely out of inspiration. Obama was elected based on inspiration alone (Well, it certainly wasn't his tenure.)

If you want to lead, you'll need to figure out how you can inspire people. If you can't inspire other people, you'll never succeed as a leader.

Loading mentions Retweet

Comments (2)

Nov 08, 2009
John Bailey said...
While I don't particularly agree with the examples you've given here in, I must say that the content and ideas resonate and are well put. I especially like the headline for this post "Leadership Without Inspiration is Management." Don't know if you are a John C. Maxwell fan, but I think he too would resonate with that statement as well.

One of the reasons why I say the examples don't best support your thesis is that some people tickle ears and appease people with what the people want to hear. I would say that is not true inspiration.

Nevertheless, again good ideas.

Nov 16, 2009
Scott Magdalein said...
Thanks John. And thanks for the offer to donate some hosting space for one of my websites. That's a huge help!
 
Got an account with one of these? Login here, or just enter your comment below.
Posterous-login    Connect    twitter